STR Industry

The New STR Economy: The Challenges Facing Independent Short-Term Rental Hosts Today

July 19,2023 | Published by


Perhaps you've heard the genesis story of Airbnb, how founders Brian Chesky and Joe Gebbia started renting air mattresses in their San Francisco apartment in 2007 to scrape together rent money. That humble "Air Bed and Breakfast" experiment blossomed into the hospitality behemoth Airbnb, now sporting a $65 billion valuation.

Many factors contributed to Airbnb’s success, but perhaps none was more integral than Chesky and Gebbia’s ability to make hosting seem as easy as throwing a few air mattresses on the floor.

Yet today, even as Airbnb has cemented  its status as the world’s largest hospitality provider, the path to successful hosting has become profoundly more challenging for the independent host. They must now navigate a short-term rental landscape fundamentally altered by fierce competition, inflated costs, and algorithmic confusion.

Take Airbnb’s ballooning inventory in the post-COVID landscape. U.S. listings swelled 23% to 1.38 million in February to August of 2022, per data provided by AirDNA. Luxury second home and investment property sales boomed during the pandemic, luring a new class of real estate investors into short-term rentals. For guests, the abundance of options is a boon. For hosts, particularly independents lacking economies of scale, the brunt of intensifying competition is unrelenting. Occupancy rates dropped by up to 10% in some markets in the wake of the supply boom last year.

AirDNA data shows the marked increase in short-term rental listings from February 2022. AirDNA data shows the marked increase in short-term rental listings from February 2022.

The costs of hosting costs are also soaring. The median mortgage payment spiked a crushing 30% in 2022 to $2,563, according to Redfin. A 2022 host survey found 45% use their Airbnb earnings to cover mortgage payments, rendering independent hosts particularly exposed. Furniture costs rose 15% over the same period, per the Consumer Price Index. Yet constrained by cutthroat competition, hosts have little latitude to lift rates - Airbnb prices crept up just 4.5% last year, says AirDNA.

Adding to host anxieties is the inscrutability of Airbnb's property search algorithms. s. Earlier this year, Airbnb launched a global marketing campaign promoting “unique stays” - properties that feature special design characteristics, amenities, or one-of-a-kind locations. Among the properties featured were a treehouse in Bavaria, a castle in Scotland, and a hollowed-out airplane in France.. Of course, it’s one thing to optimize your digital content to meet the standards of Google’s search results or Instagram’s content feed, as creators long ago learned how to do. It’s another to optimize your property for a search algorithm that can change on a whim, with little or no notice. Leaving independents and their typical homes overshadowed, this algorithmic obsession with differentiation creates a structural disadvantage, with livelihoods hanging on opaque algorithms.


Independent Airbnb hosts face a constantly evolving landscape fraught with challenges. Staying competitive demands continuous strategic investment - from enhancing listing aesthetics to improving amenities and adjusting pricing. But these efforts are complicated by macroeconomic uncertainties, rising costs, and competition from better-resourced institutional investors.Most concerning for independents is their dependence on Airbnb's opaque algorithms to drive bookings. As the company pushes "unique" properties, typical homes risk irrelevance. With livelihoods hanging in the balance, Airbnb must provide transparency into its ranking factors and give independents the tools to adapt.

The path to hosting began with air mattresses on a floor. For independent hosts to continue thriving, Airbnb must return to its roots - nurturing and empowering the individuals who built this community.


Read More